d. Recommendations .................................................................................................... 191
E. Exclusion of Evidence Obtained by Torture or Ill-Treatment and the Privilege
against Self-Incrimination ................................................................................................ 192
a.
b.
c.
d.
International Standards ............................................................................................. 192
Domestic Standards .................................................................................................. 194
Findings and Analysis .............................................................................................. 196
Recommendations .................................................................................................... 202
III. Fair Trial Guarantees and the Death Penalty ............................................................. 203
a.
b.
c.
d.
International Standards ............................................................................................. 203
Domestic Standards .................................................................................................. 203
Findings and Analysis .............................................................................................. 204
Recommendations .................................................................................................... 204
PART 3: TOWARDS THE CLOSURE OF THE GUANTÁNAMO BAY DETENTION FACILITY .......... 205
I. Release of Individuals Detained at Guantánamo ........................................................ 206
A. Challenges to the Closure of Guantánamo .............................................................. 206
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
Legislative Restrictions ............................................................................................ 207
Periodic Review Board ............................................................................................. 211
Resettlement ............................................................................................................. 213
Yemeni Detainees ..................................................................................................... 214
Recommendations .................................................................................................... 215
B. Human Rights Safeguards Related to the Closure of Guantánamo: NonRefoulement ....................................................................................................................... 215
a.
b.
c.
d.
International Standards ............................................................................................. 215
Domestic Standards .................................................................................................. 218
Findings and Analysis .............................................................................................. 219
Recommendations .................................................................................................... 224
II. Accountability and Redress .......................................................................................... 225
A. Accountability for Torture and Ill-Treatment ........................................................ 225
a. International Standards ............................................................................................. 225
b. Domestic Standards .................................................................................................. 230
c. Findings and Analysis .............................................................................................. 233
Legislation ................................................................................................................... 233
Investigations and Prosecutions................................................................................... 235
Superior Orders............................................................................................................ 240
Accountability of Other Participating States ............................................................... 241
d. Recommendations .................................................................................................... 244
B. Right to Redress ......................................................................................................... 245
a. International Standards ............................................................................................. 245
b. Domestic Standards .................................................................................................. 248
c. Findings and Analysis .............................................................................................. 251
3